Key Issues in the Development of Insulators in the Future


Key Issues in the Development of Insulators in the Future

The application of silicone composite insulators has increased significantly in the past 30 years. A key factor behind sustained growth will be the confidence that power companies have shown in them. Professor Liang Xidong and Professor Yan Zhipeng from Tsinghua University discussed some key issues and suggested that some existing IEC test methods and technical standards may need further improvement. They also reviewed the testing methods used in China, which has the world's largest insulator market. In addition, due to different operating conditions, they explained that it may be necessary to develop specific testing technical requirements for different types of composite insulators, especially for substation insulators

Since the 1980s, China's electric power industry has experienced rapid growth. With the development of UHV AC and UHV DC lines, there has been a surge in power generation and the length of the national overhead network. Figure 1 and Figure 2 depict the growth in power generation and length of overhead transmission lines from 1980 to 2016 and 1985 to 2016, respectively.

The development of insulators cannot be separated from the development of the entire power industry. For example, the rapid growth in the length of overhead lines and the movement towards higher voltage levels not only bring about a significant increase in the demand for insulators, but also pose new and higher requirements for the performance of insulators. Due to the advantages of silicone rubber composite insulators in wet and dirty flashover performance, light weight, high strength to weight ratio, convenient transportation and installation, and damage resistance, the application of silicone rubber composite insulators in China has achieved significant growth.

The statistics of the number of line insulators purchased by State Grid Corporation of China from January 2012 to September 2017 are shown in Figure 3. This data covers 110 kV to 1000 kV AC, ± 800 kV DC, and 70 kN to 550 kN SML (porcelain, glass, and silicone composite insulators) and 1000 kN SML composite insulators. During this period, State Grid purchased 34.1 million porcelain insulators, 25.3 million glass insulators, and 5.13 million strings of silicone composite insulators. If converted into the number of strings, it can be directly compared, with about 2.48 million strings for porcelain and about 1.85 million strings for glass. Therefore, the purchase proportions of ceramic, glass, and composite insulator strings are 26%, 20%, and 54%, respectively. The number of composite insulator strings in newly installed insulators is greater than the sum of the other two insulator strings. This confirms that China has become the first country to use silicone rubber insulators in ultra high voltage and ultra high voltage overhead lines.

The use of composite insulators has also increased significantly worldwide, and based on experimental applications, they now dominate all UHV lines. In addition, significant improvements have been made in both manufacturing and testing. However, considering the rapid development of this technology, the key issue for future composite insulators is that power companies still have confidence in their expected service life and performance. This means that the future development of composite insulators (as shown in Figure 4) will depend on whether there are suitable test methods to verify long-term performance; Establish different requirements for insulators in the station; Develop the best materials and maintenance techniques.

 

Test method and long-term performance

The technical standard issued to ensure the performance of composite insulators is IEC 62217, Polymer High Voltage Insulators for Indoor and Outdoor Applications - General Definitions, Test Methods, and Acceptance Criteria. Its scope includes polymer insulators whose insulators consist of one or more organic materials. The polymer insulators covered by this standard include solid and hollow insulators for overhead lines or indoor and outdoor equipment with a rated voltage greater than 1000 V. Unfortunately, the test methods in IEC 62217 do not guarantee satisfactory performance of insulators throughout their service life. For example, some composite insulators that have passed standard tests will exhibit different performance at runtime, even in similar environments. A representative issue is that such testing is not sufficient to adequately screen for interface quality, rod quality, and shed to shell interface quality.


Bar test

The current IEC standards only provide for dye penetration testing and water diffusion testing of rod materials. However, during use, rod damage is still the main cause of insulator failure, such as brittle fracture and decay fracture. For example, as shown in Table 1, core rod failures have been the main cause of service failures, accounting for approximately 22.3% of all such accidents. This indicates that the quality of the core rod is far from satisfactory, and more testing methods are needed to ensure quality and prevent such damage.

The proportion of brittle fracture in composite insulators in use is very low, but it can lead to sudden drop of insulators, causing serious consequences. Typically, affected insulators fail under low mechanical loads only after a few months or years of use. In this case, the fracture surface is usually flat and smooth, as shown in Figure 5.

From Europe to China, many countries have reported brittle fracture, but there are currently no relevant IEC tests. Since the mechanism behind this failure is clearly stress corrosion, this test method has been developed and adopted in the Chinese Electric Power Industry Standard DL/T 810-2002 (revised in 2012). Specifically, this standard requires that fiberglass rods must be acid resistant (i.e., use boron free glass). Since the publication of this standard, there have been no reports of brittle fracture of newly installed composite insulators with acid resistant rods. This type of testing helps confirm that this risk of the mandrel can be eliminated. Decay like fracture is another rod failure mechanism. Although the incidence of this phenomenon is even lower than brittle fracture, the problem is equally serious. Affected insulators can also fail under low mechanical loads, only after a few years of use. However, in this case, the fracture surface is brittle, like dead wood, as shown in Figure 6. In addition, chalk appeared on the surface of the affected insulator shed and separation of the glass fibers from the resin in the rod was found. In China, this type of fault mainly occurs on 500 kv lines. It is worth noting that this type of fault has increased in the past 10 years.

Currently, the testing in IEC standards cannot guarantee the prevention of deterioration like fracture because some core rod materials have passed, but subsequently failed in operation. In addition, the exact mechanism behind this remains unclear. Experience has shown that infrared imaging can detect local temperature increases before a fault occurs. But this only allows detection. To prevent this problem, more screening tests are needed on the bar.
Umbrella material test
In IEC standards, the test of umbrella pillars/umbrellas includes four parts: hardness test, accelerated weathering test, tracking and erosion test (1000h salt spray test), and flammability test. Based on the experience of the State Grid and China Southern Power Grid, these tests need to be improved. For example, current IEC standards do not consider hydrophobicity and its transfer. In addition, testing methods for tracking and erosion should be improved, while multi stress testing does not seem suitable for materials such as silicone rubber. Hydrophobicity and its transmissibility are the most important characteristics of composite insulators made of hydrophobic transfer materials, but they have not been mentioned in IEC. To this end, Tsinghua University proposed a test method for the hydrophobicity and transfer of silicone rubber insulators, which has been used in China for 15 years. According to the local standard DL/810-2002, the test is divided into four parts: hydrophobicity test, hydrophobicity loss test, hydrophobicity recovery test, and hydrophobicity transfer test. Each has its own test method and acceptance criteria.
Currently, there are still some problems in the methods and effects of IEC tracking corrosion tests. For example, in the 5000h salt spray test, salt spray directed insulators appear to be misleading in terms of the actual technical requirements for composite insulators under harsh service conditions. Rotating wheel inclination testing is another option for evaluating tracking and erosion performance, but unfortunately, there is a significant dispersion of results in different laboratories. Another issue is testing for larger insulator diameters, which are necessary for composite station insulators currently being developed. In addition, with the increasing application of composite insulators in high-voltage DC lines and converter stations, China has stipulated tracking and corrosion resistance tests under DC voltage, but there is no clear provision in IEC.
To ensure the long-term performance of umbrella materials, IEC recommends accelerated weathering testing. Unfortunately, based on China's experience to date, this has no impact on silicone rubber. Specifically, current experiments have not fully simulated the impact of insoluble pollutants on silicone rubber materials and the hydrophobic change process. Therefore, an improved 5000h test program - THU 5000h test program should be used in practical operation. This test procedure (see Figure 7) contains two key modifications: 1. Using mixed pollution fog (NaCl and diatomite) instead of salt fog; Provide sufficient time for hydrophobic loss and discharge activity in the fog chamber, as well as for hydrophobic transfer in the ultraviolet light chamber (as shown in Figure 8).

Test interface
Poor interface adhesion or interface coupling failure of composite insulators can lead to different types of problems, such as interface perforation, local temperature rise caused by interface leakage current, and ultimately lead to decay like fracture. In addition, there may be a relationship between weak interfacial adhesion and brittle fracture. There is evidence that this may be a growing problem because the interface between the rod and shed is always a critical area of composite insulators. IEC 62217 and other standards provide tests for interfaces and connections, including reference dry frequency tests, prestressing tests, and verification tests. The test mainly adopts 1000kV/ μ S Steep front impulse voltage test. Limited testing cannot guarantee the performance of the interface in outdoor operation for decades. In fact, the failure record of shed rod interface can be traced back to an investigation in 1900. The investigation report shows that 203 insulators failed due to interface problems. (See Table 1) If you review the situation over the past 30 years, this interface issue is very important. In fact, a survey conducted in China during this period has shown similar results.

 

Currently, the steep forward impulse voltage test conducted according to IEC 62217 and IEC 61109 does not seem to guarantee the interface quality, so the test has been modified in recent years. The applied voltage is changed from 1000 kv/ms to 30 kv/cm, which requires higher interface performance. A new approach to interface testing seems necessary. One possibility is the measurement of interfacial resistivity, recently proposed by Tsinghua University, for testing the dielectric properties between silicone rubber and fiberglass rods.
Low price and long-term performance
Due to fierce competition, silicone rubber insulators are very attractive compared to other types of market prices. This is especially true under high voltage conditions. For example, the cost comparison of ceramic insulators, glass insulators, and composite insulators for China's 110kv - 1000kv AC insulators, ± 500kv DC insulators, and ± 800kv DC insulators is shown in Figure 9a and Figure b, respectively. The cost of each insulator string is calculated based on its application in a general usage environment. It is easy to see that silicone rubber composite insulators are always much cheaper than ceramic or glass insulators, and this cost advantage increases with the increase in voltage or mechanical level. In the case of DC transmission, the cost difference is even greater.

Although the lower purchase cost is one of the advantages of silicone rubber composite insulators, low prices may increase the risk of lower quality and long-term poor performance. Based on the experience of using HTV silicone rubber in China, some insulators have operated without problems for more than 15 years, but many early products have to be replaced within 10 years. As the current service life is usually less than 20 years, this may affect users' perception and confidence in composite insulators. The new generation of synthetic rubber composite insulators is expected to operate for longer periods of time. However, due to the desire of utility companies to purchase reliable and low-cost insulators, and the need for manufacturers to control production costs, current insulator standards are insufficient to meet all these benefits.
Proposed modifications to the standard
It is urgent to modify the testing methods in current standards, but it is also important to first determine the technical requirements that must be met. Technical standards must guide insulator manufacturers to correctly understand the requirements for outdoor insulation and avoid any random changes in composition or production process. At the same time, another requirement is to guide the utility procurement process. The quality of composite insulators depends on the material, design, and manufacturing process. Therefore, in order to improve performance, it may be necessary to incorporate material, design, and manufacturing testing into future standards. Taking China as an example, DL/T 810-2002 has been in use for 15 years, with significant changes from the first generation of silicone rubber composite insulators to the second generation of silicone rubber composite insulators. As mentioned above, in order to prevent brittle fracture, stress corrosion tests were conducted, and hydrophobicity and hydrophobicity transfer tests for HTM materials were defined. Other content includes high-voltage DC transmission tracking and erosion testing, as well as several material tests on silicone rubber and fiberglass rods. The steep forward impulse voltage test of 30 kV/cm has been improved to meet the requirements of UHV AC and UHV DC in China.
Different requirements for insulators in the station
Substation is a new main application field of composite insulators, although the volume and application proportion of composite insulators in the past 20 years are far lower than that of line insulators. This situation is now changing. Although one of the reasons why silicone rubber composite insulators are now used in substations is their success on overhead lines, line insulators and station insulators operate under different conditions. The location of line insulators is scattered across the entire line, making monitoring them a challenge. In addition, due to the relatively low unit value of line insulators, it is not considered necessary to conduct full aging monitoring of line insulators. Similarly, due to the relatively simple connection between insulators and towers, line insulators can be replaced individually or in batches, so repairing any localized damage found is usually not cost-effective. This allows sampling of some or even some insulators within the overall line for monitoring and research during operation. In contrast, the relative concentration of insulators within the station provides an advantage for various monitoring purposes. In addition, due to the high individual value of station insulators, it is worthwhile to develop monitoring techniques, and any local damage found is worth repairing. At the same time, sampling research during service is almost impossible. Substation insulators are often used in high-voltage equipment, making replacement inconvenient. For example, due to different characteristics, insulators in the station can be divided into two types: Type I - easy to replace; And Type II - difficult to replace. The main example of Type I insulators is bus station posts. Type II insulators include GIS bushings, wall bushings, power transformer bushings, hollow insulators for CTs and PTs, and hollow housings for zinc oxide lightning arresters.
Service life requirements for station insulators
For type II substation insulators that are difficult to replace in use, close attention must be paid to their service life and long-term performance. For example, it has been observed that a wall sleeve that has only been in operation for 15 years has become severely aged (see Figure 10). Large areas of cracks and chalk appear on the outdoor part of the shed surface. These surface cracks mainly occur in the upper portion of the housing (i.e., exposed to sunlight). Silicone rubber pulverization occurs on the high-pressure side. Due to this pulverization, the mechanical strength of the surface decreases significantly. In addition, in most regions, such as HV and the intermediate portion, the hydrophobicity classification is reduced to HC7, and the surface water shows a hydrophilic state. The price of the core rod material is far lower than itself, and the replacement cost is also far higher than the umbrella cost. Because sampling is not possible during service, the aging process and its various mechanisms of action are more difficult to determine. This example emphasizes that monitoring the aging performance of composite insulators in substations is more important than for overhead lines.

 

 

Test methods for substation insulators
The operating conditions of substation insulators are different from those of overhead line insulators. In addition, different station equipment has specific operating conditions in terms of electric field distribution, bending stiffness, torsional stiffness, temperature, and so on. Therefore, it is best to use different tests to check these different insulators and set different acceptance criteria for each type of insulator.
New materials and maintenance techniques
Material superhydrophobicity
New superhydrophobic materials are particularly attractive for outdoor insulation, and researchers have come up with various methods to create these materials. For example, Tsinghua University has prepared specific microstructures and nanostructures on the surface of silicone rubber using laser ablation templates and fluoroalkyl silane modified composite coatings (see Figure 11).

Figure 12 shows the measurement results of static contact angle and sliding angle of HTV silicone rubber surfaces with different micro, nano, and micro nano level texture surfaces. The static contact angle of water droplets on unmodified HTV silicone rubber specimens is 115 ± 0.7 ° (i.e., Figure 12: Contact and sliding angles of original and superhydrophobic HTV specimens). (a) Contact angle and sliding angle; (b) The contact angle of a high-temperature television sample having a micro/nano structure; (c) Cavitation between water and HTV samples with micro/nano structures. Classified as hydrophobic). Under the microstructure HTV silicone rubber surface, the value increased to 151.1 ± 1.7 °, and the sliding angle was 4.1 °. The static contact angle and sliding angle of nanostructured HTV silicone rubber surface are 148.2 ° and 4.9 °, respectively. The static contact angle of HTV silicone rubber samples with micro and nano structures is the highest, 153.3 °, and the sliding angle is extremely low, 2.7 °. A super hydrophobic silicone rubber exhibits excellent water repellency when impacted by water droplets under an electric field. The surface can also solve the problems of uneven field distribution caused by surface water film and electric field enhancement caused by water droplets. This large area of sample has been successfully prepared, and it has been found that this surface also has anti icing and self-cleaning properties. Obviously, mass production of durable, ultra hydrophobic surfaces will be an important development direction in the field of outdoor insulation in the future.
Other new materials
There are other developments that deserve attention, such as nano fillers and modification of fillers. The umbrella/sheath of composite insulators or FRP rods can be better improved by improving or replacing fiber or matrix materials. Another promising development is the use of new coupling agents or new treatment methods to improve the critical interface between the sheath and the rod. Other possibilities include self-diagnosis and even self-healing materials.
 
Maintenance based on non-contact monitoring
Online monitoring is a huge challenge for power grids. The development of industrial robots will be a promising way to conduct non-contact monitoring of insulation, such as searching for any local heating that may be caused by surface leakage currents, internal defects, or degradation of the shell rod interface. Currently, it is believed that the local temperature rise is mainly related to the degradation of the interface, which is an early sign of similar decay fracture. Non contact monitoring methods such as infrared detection of helicopters or unmanned aerial vehicles can detect local heating, thereby timely replacing affected insulators based on temperature rise levels.
Big data based maintenance
Information technology is bound to change the development of power grids. In terms of composite insulators, there are two possible characteristics that may meet some of the needs of future smart grids. The first is large-scale and real-time online status monitoring of substations and overhead lines. Composite insulators can add a new function, namely, acquiring and transmitting data. The other is fault prediction based on big data. Each insulator needs to have its own QR code in order to obtain all information, such as manufacturing and material details, operation time, maintenance information, etc. With this data, quality maintenance will be digitized, and fault prediction will also be based on big data.
conclusion
The use of composite insulators has increased rapidly in the past 30 years. Looking forward to the future, there are still key issues for the sustainable development of this technology. At present, the test methods and technical standards for composite insulators are not yet perfect. In order to improve the quality and reliability of composite insulators, it is very important to improve composite insulators. Specific test methods and requirements need to be developed for different types of composite substation insulators. In addition, new materials and improved maintenance techniques will contribute to the further development of composite insulators.

 

Related News


Silicon rubber high-voltage composite insulators have many superior performances that traditional insulators cannot match

Due to the superior performance that many traditional insulators cannot match, silicone rubber high-voltage composite insulators have been increasingly used at home and abroad. The research and development of silicone rubber high-voltage composite insulators in China is relatively late, but they are also developing rapidly. According to information


Powder with high hardness, low plasticity, and high friction has poor compaction performance

The smoother the surface of the molding mold, the higher the hardness, and the greater the rigidity, the more conducive to the improvement and uniformity of the density of the damaged body; The green body density using two-way pressing is higher than that using one-way pressing,


The gate is directly related to the beauty of the plastic part. If the gate design is not good, it is prone to defects

The gate is directly related to the beauty of the plastic part. If the gate design is not good, it is prone to defects. It is easy to generate serpentine flow without any obstruction. For products with high requirements, overflow and exhaust should also be designed.


Analysis on composition and structure of plastic injection mold

Plastic injection molds are basically divided into static and dynamic molds. The injection head side of the injection molding machine with a gate sleeve is a static mold, which generally consists of a gate sleeve, a backing plate, and a template. For simple molds, it is also possible to use a thicker template instead of a backing plate.


The accuracy of the mold will become higher and higher

The mold industry is an important component of China's hardware industry. The 12th Five Year Plan period is a key period for China to properly respond to major changes in the domestic and foreign development environment and accelerate the realization of the goal of building a moderately prosperous society in an all-round way


What are the main factors affecting the mold pressing process

Powders with high hardness, low plasticity, and high friction have poor compaction performance, which can be appropriately improved by adding lubricants or molding agents; When the powder purity is low and the oxygen content is high, the pressing performance is poor,